IBS Group Hypnotherapy Study
(Harvey 1989)
In 1989, a research team (Harvey et al., 1989) at the Gastroenterology Unit of Frenchay Hospital in Bristol compared group-based and individual gut-focused hypnotherapy for IBS.
They engaged 33 patients with medically diagnosed and refractory IBS. Refractory meant it had been resistant to other treatments for at least 12 months.
The patients had four 40-minute sessions of hypnotherapy over 7 weeks.
16 patients had individual (1:1) gut-focused hypnotherapy. 5 became “symptom free”, 3 had “less symptoms” and 8 reported “no improvement”. 50% improved. This is less effective than IBS hypnotherapy studies that are reported elsewhere, where results typically help 75% to 80% of patients.
17 patients had gut-focused hypnotherapy in groups. Of those, 6 became “symptom free”, 6 had “less symptoms” and 5 reported “no improvement”. 71% improved. These patients also had group discussions about their condition and treatment.
It seems strange that group therapy appeared to have better results than individual therapy, although the sample sizes are very small, so the result may not be an accurate predictor of future performance.
The approach used here was found to be less effective for people over 50 years old.
The types of IBS triggers and symptoms was not analysed.
Hypnotherapy can help people with IBS!
Link: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(89)90013-5
Reference: Harvey, R. F., Gunary, R. M., Hinton, R. A., & Barry, R. E. (1989). Individual and group hypnotherapy in treatment of refractory irritable bowel syndrome. The Lancet, 333(8635), 424-425. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(89)90013-5
Read More Research Summaries
Our articles on Hypnotherapy for IBS Research:
| Title | Summary |
|---|---|
| The North Carolina Protocol IBS Hypnotherapy | The North Carolina Protocol for IBS using gut-focused Hypnotherapy is a well-established and evidence-based treatment. |
| Manchester Approach for IBS Gut-focused Hypnotherapy | The Manchester Approach for IBS Gut-focused Hypnotherapy was developed in 1984, and provides an evidence-based approach treatment for IBS. |
| IBS Hypnotherapy mini-review (Hauser 2024) | IBS Hypnotherapy mini-review concludes hypnotherapy can help IBS (Hauser 2024) |
| IBS Hypnotherapy Study Whorwell 1984 | IBS Hypnotherapy Study helped 15 out of 15 refractory IBS patients and was far more beneficial than psychotherapy. (Whorwell 1984) |
| IBS Hypnotherapy Study Whorwell 1987 | IBS Hypnotherapy Study shows long-term effectiveness. (Whorwell 1987) |
| IBS Group Hypnotherapy Study Harvey 1989 | IBS individual vs Group Hypnotherapy study (Harvey 1989) showed both can help. |
| IBS Hypnotherapy Study | IBS Hypnotherapy helped 11 patients. (Galovski 1998) |
| IBS Hypnotherapy Research: 1000 Patients (Miller 2015) | IBS Hypnotherapy helped 76% of 1000 patients (Miller 2015) |
| Hypnotherapy for IBS Study of 6 vs 12 sessions (Hasan 2021) | 6 sessions of IBS hypnotherapy helped 79% participants, while 12 sessions helped 74% in a study of 448 people (Hasan 2021). |
| IBS Group Hypnotherapy Study | IBS Group Hypnotherapy Study (Lovdahl 2022) shows individual and group hypnotherapy can help IBS. |
| IBS Hypnotherapy Patient Expectation Study | IBS Hypnotherapy Patient Expectation Study (Donnet 2022). The patient’s expectations did not appear to impact the outcome. |
| IBS Hypnotherapy NICE NHS Recommendation CG61 2008 | IBS Hypnotherapy NICE NHS Recommendation (2008 Research Recommendation CG61) |
| Gut-directed hypnotherapy vs low FODMAP diet for IBS | Study found efficacy gut-directed hypnotherapy is similar to FODMAP diet for the treatment of irritable bowel syndrome (Peters, 2016) |
More Information
If you think there’s research that we should add, or if you have any related comments, questions, suggestions or ideas, please let us know:
